The Lakeshore Lutheran League (LLL) controls the interscholastic sports that are offered at Bethany. The LLL is a group of 16 Lutheran schools, divided into 2 divisions, which plan and coordinate interscholastic sports activities for the students of these lakeshore area schools. Bethany is in  Division 1 along with First German - Manitowoc, Immanuel - Manitowoc, Trinity - Brillion, Zion - Wayside, St. John’s - Newtonburg, St. Paul’s - Algoma, and St. Peter’s - Sturgeon Bay. More information about the LLL can be found at www.lakeshorelutheranleague.net.